When the Data Disagrees

A platform migration created the opportunity for a reset, stepping back from years of accumulated decisions to find a cleaner, more focused experience that served both the brand and its users.

Vermont Teddy Bear had built a strong brand and a complicated digital experience. Years of accumulated decisions had layered complexity onto a platform seeing more than 70% mobile traffic. Animation-heavy components, dense layouts, and a desktop-first approach that hadn't caught up with how users were actually arriving. The challenge wasn't to reinvent the brand. It was to bring clarity to it.

  • Role:
  • Senior UX Designer
  • Scope:
  • UX modernization, mobile-first design, cross-functional education

The Problem: Preference Over Evidence

Good ideas, strong brand, genuine intent, but users weren't responding. Without evidence to guide decisions, the experience had drifted toward expression over clarity, and there was no reliable way to know what was actually working for the people using it. The migration was the chance to change that.

Key challenges:

  • Layered promotional messaging creating visual noise
  • Animation-heavy components competing for attention
  • Desktop-first layouts serving a 70%+ mobile audience
  • No structured testing framework to validate or challenge decisions

The Thinking

The goal wasn't to strip the brand down: Vermont Teddy Bear's identity was a genuine asset. The thinking was simpler: get back to what works. Competitive research and behavioral data pointed toward a more normalized experience, one where users could navigate, discover, and make decisions with confidence. Years of accumulated elements - animations, layered content, custom flows - had drifted from market standards in ways that weren't serving users. The redesign was about finding the right balance: removing what wasn't earning its place while preserving what made the brand worth experiencing.

The Solutions

Simplifying the Experience

The redesign centered on one principle: get out of the user's way. Navigation was simplified to reduce friction and make it easier for users to find what they were looking for without getting lost. Animation density was reduced and the homepage was rebuilt as a discovery tool, giving users a clearer path forward. Every layout decision was made mobile-first, reflecting where more than 70% of traffic actually was.

Building a Mobile-First Culture

Desktop-first thinking was deeply embedded, not out of resistance, but habit. Shifting it required less of a mandate and more of a demonstration. By consistently leading with mobile designs in every review and collaboration session, the question of how something worked on mobile gradually became part of every conversation. The shift wasn't imposed. It was shown.

Outcomes

This project wasn't measured in a single conversion lift. It was measured in how the team changed and what the data consistently pointed toward.

  • Design decisions became faster and more confident, grounded in evidence rather than assumption
  • Product and content discoverability improved significantly, allowing users to navigate with greater confidence and depth than before
  • Mobile engagement increased meaningfully as the experience caught up with where users actually were
  • Marketing and content teams gained the autonomy to act independently, removing bottlenecks that had slowed execution for years
  • Testing opportunities expanded significantly, no longer dependent on development cycles to validate ideas

Reflection

This project marked a turning point, from executing to leading. 'Meet users where they are' became a design philosophy that persisted well beyond this project, changing how the organization made decisions. That kind of shift, from preference to evidence, from brand-first to user-first, is the work that creates lasting change.

Up Next:

Early Lessons in Design Leadership - Introduced prototyping workflows, design systems, and real-time collaboration to a multi-brand organization, giving teams visibility into design decisions for the first time.

Read Case Study
  • Contact:
  • toddunn@gmail.com
  • © 2026